« video! my presentation in toronto | Main | my 2-day network design course returns to australia »

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Aldonius

Couple of things:

- If you look at the bottom of the key (bottom left hand corner) you will find the text '© Henry Chin 2013'.
- The tumblr (second) link is broken.

Certainly an incredible piece of work!

hU0N

I'm curious, as someone who has never been to New York, how do you rate this network?

At first look, it appears to be a good example of a well gridded frequent network, with high capacity infrastructure on the dominant routes within the grid (ie the subway lines). But everything I read about the MTA system talks about it as though it is the worst kind of radial system, where you'd be mad to take a journey to lower Manhattan any other way than by transit, but anywhere to anywhere journeys are almost impossible except by car.

Do you think the network is actually good? And if so, why does it seem to have a reputation of not working for anywhere to anywhere journeys?

Rolando

I wonder how it counts frequency on corridors with multiple routes... Even if the two services using the same route run only every 20 minutes there'd still be 10 minute frequencies on the corridor.

Henry

I can't believe I'm seeing this here. It's been a long time since I've made that map, and I almost forgot about it...

@hUON: The frequencies on the grid routes are very good, and if you've got time the buses work fine for intra-borough routes. However, the major issue with the system in New York is not that it's infrequent, but that it's slow. A trip from, say, Floral Park to Flushing, is 1 hour and ten minutes by bus, but 15 to 20 minutes by car on a good day. Inter-borough travel is even worse; it will usually be faster to take the train into Manhattan than it will be to take the bus between boroughs.

The two bus operators in New York (NYCT and MTA Bus) have some of the lowest speeds in the nation, and are two of the only three agencies that have average bus speeds below 10MPH. This is mostly because in New York, the local streets are slow, and there's not much you can do about it (the biggest transfer points are also the most congested areas).

@Rolando: Routes in New York don't actually share a main road most of the time (with the exception of Manhattan). Outside of Manhattan, the Bx40/42, Q20/44, Q25/34, and Q110/113 were all shown using dotted lines on their infrequent segments. Non-frequent routes sharing a trunk weren't depicted on the Manhattan section of the map to increase legibility.

ajedrez

There are a few corridors on Staten Island that have service running every 10 minutes or better when you combine two lines (though they aren't spaced out perfectly evenly). And the S53/S79 from SI to Bay Ridge run every 10 minutes or better for most of the day. (This is individually)

Anon256

Yeah, Staten Island is missing from this map, but it barely merits inclusion. I made http://goo.gl/maps/f91xL mapping those segments with 10-minute midday frequencies. Notably neither the Staten Island Railway nor the ferry comes close to this standard (both are half-hourly at midday). Not even the S79 "Select Bus Service" is frequent on its own (with 15-minute midday headways), though for most of its route it shares with either the S59 or the S78 yielding frequent service at the shared stops.

Staten Island seems ripe for a network redesign with more emphasis on frequent corridors, possibly at the expense of weekday-only coverage routes (e.g. the S42, S55 and S56). Unlike the rest of NYC, buses can actually manage respectable average speeds in Staten Island, so a well-designed network could be really useful.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

the firm

Jarrett is now in ...

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...