« dissent of the week ii: new york's select bus service | Main | los angeles: rail has "forced ridership down"? »

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83454714d69e20133f26f2f96970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference munich: the station as riot:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

ws

It's very modern and sleek looking but it's not cold or sterile. Absolutely stunning from those pics.

Cap'n Transit

Wow, that's pretty colorful. New York's Independent Subway took color-coding to the extreme - even if it was realized in a much subtler way.

rhywun

Wow. Forget the mirrors and neon colors - look how clean it is! As a New Yorker, I can only shake my head in wonder that my stations are characterized not by bright colors and cleanliness, but by paint falling off the ceiling, random puddles of water, and strange smells. Sigh.

Herbie

Quibble: Münchner Freiheit is not a weaved station, but merely a station where lines U3 and U6 split from each other. No cross platform advantage. Both northbound lines are on different tracks due to the need for U3 to quickly rise and cross over U6 on its way to the Olympic Park. The station would actually be better served with a single island platform. The stations Innsbrucker Ring and Scheidplatz, however, are weaved stations.

The architecture of the Munich U-Bahn stations is truly stunning. Wish I could visit again.

Gallery of every station in the Munich U-Bahn system.
http://www.muenchnerubahn.de/netz/bahnhoefe/liste/

anonymouse

NYCT for some reason has a policy of painting the ceiling above the trackways black. Perhaps this has something to do with the American philosophy that the tracks are next to the station, not inside it, so the trackway space has to be excluded from the space of the station.

Tom West

1) The gallery Herbie linekd to seems to contain a whole host of useful information. If I knew German and was new to the city, it would make me feel a lot more comfortable about taking the U-Bahn.
2) Black on the ceiling is terriebl, terrible thing. The (main line) Birmingham New Street station in the UK is mostly underneath a shopping mall (to the extent that legally, it is an underground station), and they painted the space above the tracks black. Granted, the number of diesel trains using that station mean that all white would be a bad plan, but some non-black would help things. Combined with teh lack of lighting, it makes for a station darker and more dreary than any Tube station.

anonymouse

Tom West, I entirely agree with you. The worst part is, when they re-build the station, they paint the trackway ceiling white first, so the station looks bright and cheerful for a while, until they paint it black. Note though that it's just the area above the track. There's actually a line on the ceiling between the space above the track (black) and the space above the platform (usually white).

Jarrett at HumanTransit.org

It sounds like the NYC issue that you're all discussing is related to how low the ceiling is.  Note how high it is in this Munich station.  And of course, non-electric trains never use these tracks.

Ezra

I don't see orange in the architecture there, I just see the pea green. Am I missing something?

anonymouse

Actually, in NYC, some stations have quite high ceilings. Chambers Street on the J comes to mind, as does Utica Avenue on the A/C. Even then, with the 20 foot ceilings, the space above the platform is painted white while the space above the track is painted black. It makes even less sense than the same arrangement in the somewhat more typical (of NYC) low-ceilinged station.

lacoste shoes

A friendship founded on bussiness is better than business founded on friendship. Do you understand?

rhywun

I have very fond memories of a trip to Munich I took as a teenaged exchange student living in Würzburg around 1986. Like many "average" Germans, we drove most everywhere as a rule but never hesitated to take transit when it made sense. It was Oktoberfest, so transit was even more welcome after a long evening of excellent beer and pretzels. Anyway, Munich was perhaps my first "big-city" experience and I was greatly impressed - It remains one of my favorite cities today - more so than other big cities I visited like Berlin or Paris. I found Munich to be more gemütlich than most cities, including my current NYC.

tomtakt

Well...I missed this post originally, but I rode through this station everyday for a year through most of the construction for the new interior.

As they were installing panels we tried to give them the benefit of the doubt on the color scheme, but I honestly find the result rather garish. I'm all for bold design, but these colors clash to an extreme. Although...I guess it's alright to have one station that clashes just for the sake of clashing, but in that case I wish it were at least a bit more adventurous in form.

A handful of the Munich U-bahn stations are really cool though--I like Königsplatz with the statue replicas from nearby museums, and the grass-covered station entrances at Garchingforschungszentrum (http://tinyurl.com/39cwvsj).

And I'm not sure if you saw, but there's a brand new tram station that complements Münchner Freiheit above ground. (ttp://tinyurl.com/338n2wv) Also quite modern!

And, lastly, I hope you had a chance to ride one of the newly built U-bahn trains. With their unbroken interior space, they are the most incredible trains I've ever seen or ridden. (http://tinyurl.com/3966loy) (http://tinyurl.com/3648pwo)

Ah, Munich...if it were a little more socially progressive, I might never have left!

The comments to this entry are closed.

the firm

Jarrett is now in ...

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...