« dissent of the week: should minimum walking distance be measured round trip? | Main | salon: it's time to love the bus »

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83454714d69e201630248e2fe970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference request for information: bus stops on diamond freeway interchanges:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Jacob Riger

The Denver region has several - for example, most of the interchanges along US 36 between Denver and Boulder

David Seater

Seattle has one: I-5 and 45th street. Route 44 crosses on 45th, numerous freeway buses. The interchange ramps are a little weird, though, not a classic diamond.

Nathan LeMesurier

There's one in Bothell, WA where I-405 intersects Bothell-Everett Highway at Canyon Park. There's also a freeway pedestrian overpass there too.

DML

Minneapolis: Washington Avenue (fwy section at U of Mn East Bank) at Cedar Avenue.

St paul: I94 at Snelling.

DB

Calgary does this on Crowchild Trail at 33rd Avenue (with connection, and plans for a more elaborate freeway-shoulder BRT service), as well as on Glenmore Trail at Elbow Drive. Functionally they are provided for, with stairs and sidewalks, but they're not nice places to be...

Nicholas Barnard

There are probably more in Seattle worth sleuthing for. (Seriously, go to OneBusAway and start peeking, I'm quite sure you'll find more than I know about.)

That being said NE 40th St & 520 in Redmond, WA kinda fits the bill. Its got a whole transit center to the southeast corner of the intersection.

bardak

While I'm sure that you are aware of them Vancouver has two on highway 99. one at Stevenson highway an another at Ladner tunk. And the 91 has one at Westminster and one at Cliveden drive on Annacis island.

Plattypus1

Not quite this design, but the El Monte Busway along I-10 has a lot of stops where the bus exits on to a special bus-only lane parallel to the freeway, and a sidewalk provides access from the arterial. See Puente Ave/I-10 in Baldwin Park for an example.

Matt Conway

Golden Gate Transit has lots of these along 101 in Marin County. Some have park-and-rides located in the diamond (or cloverleaf, which is also common); I think quite a few have connections with other lines.

Kyle

Calgary, Alberta, Canada:
Crowchild Trail SW and Flanders Ave
Crowchild Trail SW and 33 Ave
14 Ave and 14 St NW

Jonathon

Recent expansions of Ottawa's transitway have eschewed grade-separated stations in favour of standard (at least in Ontario) par-clo highway interchanges. There are quite a few of these (though no diamonds I can recall) the Queensway/Jeanne D'arc Boulevard where local buses from the west half of the Orleans suburb connect with the frequent 95 bus to downtown without having to double back to the main Orleans bus terminal.

d

A few examples from Melbourne:

Examples with bus on intersecting street:
Eastern Freeway / Wetherby Road/Middleborough Road, Blackburn North

Examples without bus on intersecting street:
Calder Freeway / Kings Road, Taylors Lakes (opened earlier this year)
Western Freeway / Leakes Road, Rockbank
Eastern Freeway / Doncaster Road, Doncaster (outbound direction only)

Kristin

Another Twin Cities example is I-35W at 66th St.

Rob Fellows

Jarrett, Seattle has many of these. On I-405 this was the primary treatment when HOV lanes were located on the right-side; even now that HOV lanes have moved to the median side several remain. There are also a few of these on I-5 despite having HOV lanes on the median side; Star Lake and SR 516 come to mind. We also have freeway stations on the right side, but also on the left side at direct access ramp locations. Let me know what sort of information would be the most useful.

Moaz Yusuf Ahmad

Petaling Jaya, Malaysia (just outside of Kuala Lumpur) at the interchange of the Federal Highway and Jalan Utara (North Road)/Jalan Barat (West Road).

The area is known as Petaling Jaya New Town or "PJ" State. The LRT (mini-metro) station nearby is called Asia Jaya.

Cheers, Moaz

www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=688446910

In Victoria, BC-
Hwy 1 and Helmcken
The other Hwy 1 intersections have different ramp structures.

Johann Tay

Melbourne, Aus - Eastern Freeway/Middleborough Rd. Does exactly what you describe.

John

Not quite identical, but Milwaukee has a couple of really nice park and rides at freeway interchanges. See Ryan Rd and College Rd on I-94.

Tony

Seattle: Montlake & SR 520

http://g.co/maps/u2e9x

This one is a bit odd because it's three-parts diamond, but one part cloverleaf--however, it's not functionally different than what you're describing.

Focusing on the inbound 520 aspect, there's a nearside, bus-only lane and stop divergent from exit traffic to Montlake in what otherwise would be shoulder, where there's a stop on NB Montlake at the top. Passengers walk on a sidewalk along the exit ramp to connect.

For outbound 520, it's basically the same, except the bus stop in the freeway is farside instead, presumably due to the odd hairpin ramp on the southwest quarter of the interchange.

Used to use it everyday to and from work when I lived in the U-District and worked for Microsoft.

Also, look east of there, if you find yourself bored, ever, and wanting to study broken, abandoned ramps over swamp. It's real weird around there.

eric darwin

Ottawa Canada: Hwy 417 at Pinecrest. Queensway at Jeanne D'Arc.

Jeff Youngstrom

Doesn't look like anyone mentioned the Bellevue, WA left-lane exit version at I-90 and 142nd Place SE.

There's also a freeway stop at I-90 and 80th Ave SE on Mercer Island.

And a third at I-90 and Rainier Ave S in Seattle.

Leigh Holcombe

One of the most interesting solutions I've seen is the Montlake Terrace Freeway Station on I-5, north of 236th St SW (north of Seattle). The bus exits to the left and enters a facility situated between the northbound and southbound freeway lanes. There is a pedestrian bridge from there that goes over the freeway to a Park&Ride which is serviced by other bus routes.

Daniel

Melbourne, Westgate Freeway (route 232) and Williamstown Road (route 472).

Map: http://www.metlinkmelbourne.com.au/assets/Maps/Localities/PDFs/21_Hobsons_Bay.pdf

Aerial photo (of freeway stops)
http://www.nearmap.com/?ll=-37.825271,144.880161&z=19&t=k&nmd=20120215

shaun

Looks like a lot of seattle comments :) - one more
SR 522 at 131st Ave NE in Woodinville (this is the served by the 522 DT to Woodinville route offered by Sound Transit - and possibly other routes)

David Marcus

I used to catch the bus every day at I-405 & Coal Creek Parkway in Bellevue, WA. http://g.co/maps/ack5b

Wad

In L.A.'s San Fernando Valley, along US101 there are commuter bus stops at the Reseda and Van Nuys boulevards ramps. (There are also freeway turnout stops in Hollywood and Echo Park).

Philip

San Diego: University ave ramps off the 15. http://g.co/maps/qrvay

Alan

Los Angeles area:
- I-10 and Puente Ave.
- I-10 and Azusa Ave.
- I-10 and Via Verde
- I-10 and Fairplex Dr. (westbound only)
- I-110 and Carson St.
- I-110 and Pacific Coast Hwy.

Tristram

In Helsinki : the bus stays on the highway and there are stairs from the highway to the street level
http://g.co/maps/6fzaq

Jim Moore

And while not a diamond, I-5 at 112th St in South Everett there is a park and ride in the middle of the freeway. When it was built, it created an HOV on and off ramp which is, what I would guess some would call an inverted diamond?

Hamilton Transit History

Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Hwy 401 & Keele St

Louis Hoffman

New Jersey has a lot of highway bus stops especially on Routes 3 & 4. Two commuter highways which go to the Lincoln Tunnel & the GW Bridge respectively. In Clifton there are some dangerous ones Route 3 and Main Ave, Route 3 and Route 7 which serve commuter bus routes. Up by the many malls in Paramus there are many stops along highways. Two that come to mind are Route 4 at Forest Ave in Paramus and Route 4 Service Road at Main St in River Edge. The last one actually pulls off the highway onto that service road with a ped overpass. Hope that helps. Awesome blog!

Peter Laws

Montreal. Autoroute 20 and Boul St Jean in Pointe Claire. Numerous STM (http://stm.info/) routes connect. Commuter rail nearby but does not connect. Bus lanes to navigate intersection added c.1984 - before that, WB buses stopped on highway with stairs to the overpass, EB unchanged.

Also, making that original connection in the winter *sucked*! :-)

Peter

David Bickford

In Phoenix, the intersection of the SR51 Freeway & Shea Boulevard and the intersection of the I17 Freeway & Bell Road. Both have express bus park-and-rides built alongside freeway entrance ramps with local route on intersecting streets a short walk away.

Zach Shaner

In suburban Seattle, I-405/30th St in Kennydale. It's the simplest form of diamond interchange, and it's served in both directions by the Bellevue-SeaTac-Burien express bus (560)and a couple peak-only runs.

Charley Ferrari

If you want a more urban example check out the BX26 going down Bedford park Blvd in the Bronx and crossing the Grand Concourse. Through traffic goes through a tunnel, but turning traffic gets routed to either side above ground. The bus goes to a bus stop on the above ground section and then rejoins Bedford Park Blvd on the other side:

http://maps.google.com/?ll=40.871079,-73.886586&spn=0.003821,0.009645&t=h&z=17&layer=c&cbll=40.871239,-73.886776&panoid=EBlwvvZrRl3m7c-xlvMlxg&cbp=12,317.99,,0,5.21

MarkS

Edmonton, AB
-Whitemud Drive and 53 Ave (Routes 30, 32, 33)
-Wayne Gretzky Dr and 118 Ave (Routes 2 and 99) (definitely an example of what *not* to do to facilitate transferring)

Madkirk

Los Angeles: Alvarado & the 101

Shaun

I believe that I-94 and Ryan Rd. in Milwaukee is an example. I can't be sure because I do not frequent the area, however.

Keep Houston Houston

Houston's Route #18 does this on Allen Parkway, at Waugh and Montrose. In the Eastbound direction there's a continuous feeder road. Westbound the bus gets off and on again twice in about a mile.

Mike C.

Here's one in Milwaukee. Intercity buses (Badger Bus) exit I-94 at 84th St and serve a stop WB near side on a pork chop and EB far side, then reenter. Local MCTS Rt 67 has service on 84th.
43.027353, -88.017288 (lat, long)

Here are a few examples in Seattle that I don't think were mentioned yet, specifically diamonds, not center-access ramps:
47.648478, -122.376381 15th Ave W
47.654423, -122.137819 SR-522 at NE 51st
47.734008, -122.324790 NE 145th
47.391675, -122.290930 Kent-Des Moines Rd
47.357862, -122.296520 S 272nd

Jarrett Stewart

http://g.co/maps/vyf3h

Pittsburgh Rt. 28 highway on the North Side has a bus stop on the side of the highway. Click the link above to be taken to the location on Google Maps.

In Brisbane

I would say look at Perth's train system's Mandurah and Joondalup lines. It's not buses but same deal.

a

Melbourne Route 232. West Gate Fwy & Williamstown Rd.

Joseph Alacchi

Montreal. Autoroute 40 at Acadie, Viau, Lacordaire, Langelier.

Used by express bus 460 during rush hours.

Andrew

Helsinki, on the Länsiväylä expressway (Highway 51) and Ring 1 (Highway 101), near the Nokia headquaters. Numerous express bus that use the freeway stop here. A subway extension is proposed in this area.

David M

Jarret - in Victoria BC

1. Royal Oak and Pat Bay Highway (Hwy 17) - express bus stops on the ramps and local buses use the on-street bus exchange. The ramp stops are part of the terminus actually.

2. MacTavish Rd and Pat Bay Highway (near Sidney BC) - while a diamond interchange, the ramps lead into two traffic circles. Highway express buses stop on the ramps connected by dedicated pedestrian bridge to a bus exchange and park and ride.

Joshua Kelley

I-5 and Kent-Des Moines Rd south of Seattle. Specifically the northbound exit: buses cross Kent-Des Moines Rd and vear left into a bus-only lane at the park-and-ride, then continues back to the on-ramp. Westbound buses on Kent-Des Moines Rd vear to the right into the bus lane, then merge back into traffic.

http://g.co/maps/n459b

Dexter Wong

Honolulu has a similar arrangement along the Moanalua Freeway, Interstate H-210. Between Moanalua Valley and Red Hill (on the western edge of Urban Honolulu), there are two frontage roads (one on either side of the freeway), that serve Kaiser Hospital, a church and finally the Red Hill neighborhood and Aliamanu Crater Military Housing. The 43, 53 and 54 buses serve three stops westbound (Moanalua Valley WB, Kaiser Hospital, Red Hill WB)and two stops eastbound (Red Hill EB, Moanalua Valley EB). Moanalua Valley WB is built atop a high overpass that Moanalua Valley Road passes through on its way to that neighborhood. A passenger bound for the valley walks down a curved off-ramp that meets the road. Passengers headed for Honolulu go under the freeway to reach Moanalua Valley EB. WB hospital passenger alight in front of the hospital, but must take a bus to Red Hill to return east (or walk on the sidewalk to Red Hill). EB hospital passengers get off at Red Hill and then cross on an overpass before walking down the sidewalk to the hospital. The Red Hill stops are either side of a tall overpass which holds the road connecting Red Hill with Aliamanu Crater. The WB buses continue on to Aiea, Pearl City and Waipahu, while the EB buses stop there on their way to Honolulu.

Eric O

I saw an interesting interchange idea for the BRT alternative of the future Southeast Corridor (the Silverline) in Charlotte, which runs on the median (in a dedicated or HOV lane). It was to bring the guideway up to the crossover street via its own dedicated ramp in the median.

Unfortunately, I believe I saw that the station platforms were placed on the side of the bridge, not the BRT ramps. I can't remember this detail exactly, but it concerns me now. If the buses have to turn off onto the bridge road and laboriously recirculate back down to the median on the other side, it would kinda lose the point. (I'm not 100% sure, but I'll try to check on this.) While allowing the platforms to be shared with connecting local routes, making the vehicle turn on the bridge to serve a station above would slow the entire BRT system with the time lost making the turnaround.

I would love to find out if someone has already taken the idea where it should go: allowing the BRT buses to shoot straight across the traffic lanes(with signalization)to exit mid-bridge back down to the median directly without the need to do a turnaround. Why not? We stop traffic all the time on drawbridges for passing ships. (Charlottean designers, I'm afraid, will probably demand that the vehicles go off-line anyway to serve park & rides and TODs better, but nevertheless...)

Brian

I recall taking a GO Bus in Toronto several years ago from York Mills terminal west to Pearson airport, and the bus pulling off the 401 at Keele (?) in the manner described above, with a stop on the far side of the intersection. Not sure if that route or stop still exists though.

Alon Levy

I don't know a single example, not from direct experience nor from that of people I know who might tell me about this. This is no accident - when bus routes look like this, I take a taxi, find someone to drive with, or avoid the trip. The urbanism is just awful. Why would I want to cross a freeway and walk along a bunch of nothing to get to the bus? Of course, I'm not the only person who feels this way, and so buses to such areas have a low ridership-low frequency vicious cycle. If I'm riding a bus, it's probably because the stations I use look like this and this.

Tom

There are several locations like that around Bergen, Norway:

E16 near Helleveien (Norwegian School of Economics stop)
E16 in Eidsvåg
Route 555 at crossing of Sotraveien and Lyderhornsveien
E39 Fritz Riebers Rd and Troldhaugveien

Heikki Salko

Helsinki (my hometown) has already been mentioned a few times, but I think the example closest to this request is off Itäväylä [route 170] at Siilitie metro station. It's slightly lost in the jumble of the overengineered T-interchange with Viikintie, but on its own it fits all of the criteria in the post.

http://g.co/maps/xze3p

Regional bus lines of the 800 series stop on the ramps with line 79 running on the crossing street and line 58 making a turn between these.

Other than that, the majority of interchanges here where there's any bus service at all have dedicated bus ramps with stops on them, which are then connected with crossing streets and other transportation infrastructure with pedestrian ramps and stairways. Not all of them work very well in bringing passengers close to their destinations, but there's a lot of them nonetheless. Plain diamond interchanges are somewhat rare here, which might be (part of) the root cause. Some examples:

* Most of Länsiväylä [hwy 51] west of Lauttasaari
* Lahdenväylä [hwy 4/7/E75] at Viikki
* Tuusulanväylä [hwy 45] at Käpylä railway station (first exit from motorway) and Pakilantie (second), where the well-used orbital bus line 550 has stops on the overbridge
* Ring III [hwy 50/E18] between the railway at Tikkurila and airport road [route 135], including the 45/50 interchange on both highways
* Ring I [route 101] below Pukinmäki railway station (with stairs directly to the platform) – arguably even fits Jarrett's criteria since the bus ramps aren't directly connected with the mainline and a bus line running across the crossing street is being reintroduced soon after some years of a different routing

Similar setups can be seen even at rural motorway exits for long-distance buses even though they definitely don't see much use.

Joel Haasnoot

We have several of these in the Netherlands. Some examples:
- Bus stop here as part of an onramp to the A12 highway http://g.co/maps/7tsr5
- On the N34 (not interstate but "state route") near the town of Borger - http://g.co/maps/a7sdc
- One of the best examples: On the A1 near Naarden
http://g.co/maps/4uuhx

If you want more, there's more options available. Some have bike storage options, some are special exists on the actual highway only accesable by bike, some have buttons to alert the driver to stop there, etc.

PS

You're probably familiar with it, but Trimet’s Line 58 does this along US 26 at the Sylvan interchange in Portland. However, there is no intersecting bus service.

Al Dimond

People have mentioned the Montlake Freeway Station in Seattle, but it actually doesn't meet Jarrett's criteria (the stop is on the level of the freeway, so buses don't cross the arterial at-grade; rather passengers climb down to freeway-level). As it happens, the stop is slated for removal with the 2014 rebuild of SR-520; the replacement will be roughly similar to what Jarrett is talking about, probably with service patterns similar to the I-5/NE 45th St freeway station (frequent, all-day service except during the forward peak, during which the U District is served by buses that go there directly).

Tomtakt

The buses from the Hauptbahnhof in Mainz, Germany to the Universität Mainz take a route along a grade-separated expressway, and have stops at a modified diamond interchange, as can be viewed here on Google Maps:
http://g.co/maps/95gzn

The bus stop (Haltestelle) called Universität in the upper right of this bus line diagram is essentially what you are referring to:
http://www.mvg-linien.de/pdf/hsup_15.pdf

Many of the buses exit the expressway and then re-enter. Then there is another bus stop actually on the expressway just a little further west at the stop called F.-v.-Pfeiffer-Weg.

Eric O

Fantastic. In answer to my own query, I found an example with the bus stops along the median running alignment (for through vehicles) on a median direct access ramp, in case anyone is interested: http://g.co/maps/ntmva (the I-90 Eastgate Park & Ride access in Bellevue, WA).

Thanks Jeff and the folks above for cluing me in to the Seattle area median lines!

While this stop is on a HOV direct access ramp a similar concept oughta work for BRT guideways ramping to the crossing arterial. The stops basically flange out over the freeway, so they don't take any lane space away. Very sweet.

(Sorry this is slightly off topic.)

Wei

In Singapore, along the Ayer Rajah Expressway. Buses headed west will do this at the Normanton Park exit (there are two bus stops, one on the exiting sliproad, one on the entry sliproad).

Andrew

Highway 401 and Keele is home to a large Government of Ontario office complex. Many GO buses on the 401 routes from York Mills/Yorkdale/Finch stop there. (This highway unfortunately suffers from severe rush hour traffic congestion, being one of the busiest highways in the world so the buses are very slow in this stretch.)

D Pike

Toronto, ON Canada
Don Valley Parkway at Eglinton Ave East

Ellentee11

I-5/SR 509 interchange in Kent, WA - half diamond half clover interchange with bus stops on the north and southbound ramps.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

the firm

Jarrett is now in ...

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...